Homily for the Memorial of Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton
Preached on January 4, 2011 at St. Andrew Catholic Church, Harrodsburg KY
Readings: 1 John 3:7-10; Psalm 98:1, 7-8, 9; John 1:35-42
By the age of 29, Elizabeth Ann Seton was a widow with five children. She had lost a husband and a fortune, and her curiosity about the Catholic Church was costing her her place in the New York high society into which she had been born and bred. She tried to remain an earnest Episcopalian but something—or Someone—greater was drawing her away from the faith of her childhood, her family, and her friends.
One Sunday, she attended St. Paul’s Chapel on Broadway where, she later wrote, “I got in a side pew which turned my face towards the Catholic Church in the next street, and found myself twenty times speaking to the Blessed Sacrament there, instead of looking at the naked altar where I was” (cf. Mrs. Seton: Foundress of the American Sisters of Charity by Joseph I. Dirvin, CM, p. 154). She had gone to seek her soul’s consolation in that chapel but found that the Real Presence she was looking for was someplace else.
Elizabeth Ann Seton realized that she was no longer content with bare sanctuaries and empty promises. She craved for the lavish meal of the Eucharist and the fullness of the Truth. She could no longer deny the hunger within her that cried for Christ and on March 14, 1805 she was received into the Catholic Church. She knew that her conversion would cut her off from her worldly connections and it did. Yet, it also cemented her celestial connection: at her first Holy Communion, she exclaimed with conviction, “at last, God is mine and I am His!” (Dirvin, p. 168).
Throughout the millennia, many others like Mother Seton have found themselves looking for something more, yearning for Someone Great. By God’s grace, somebody always pointed them to the right direction. John the Baptist did so with two of his disciples when he said of Jesus, “Behold, the Lamb of God” (Jn. 1:36). Our parish patron Andrew brought his brother Simon Peter to meet the promised Messiah (Jn. 1:41-42). It was the Filicchi family who first invited Mother Seton to come to Mass. So many more out there are looking for what and whom we have here. We too need to extend to them the invitation that Christ gave to His first disciples: “Come, and you will see” (Jn. 1:39).




A reader sends us the following report from the Diocese of Lexington, Kentucky:
Unfortunately, the human race does not have a good track record when it comes to hospitality to the Most High. When the Christ-child “came unto His own…His own received Him not” (Jn. 1:11). There was no room for Him in any inn in Bethlehem (cf. Lk. 2:7); there was no great reception for Him who is the world’s Redeemer. He was the long-expected One, yet only a few noticed that He had come: those who were attentive to the things of Heaven (the Magi) and those who were down to earth (the shepherds). There were even those who did not want Him around, who were ready to kill just to get Him out of their way (cf. Mt. 2:3, 16). But, the rest did not detect the Divine coming to dwell in their midst, so consumed were they with their cares that they cared not to watch or wait for the window of salvation to open.
Such common sense might work well in the South, but, it cannot take the place of conscience in a Christian. At the heart of what we believers call conscience are two truths: first, that all humanity is broken; and second, that change would do us a whole lot of good.
The well-mannered of the West would find it quite offensive that, not only do we not say grace, my family allows—nay, encourages—burping during a meal. Burping, I was told by my late aunt Victoria, is natural; it is the body’s response to an appetite that is satisfied, to a stomach that is full. Some of the cooks in my family even look forward to hearing burps from around the table. Somehow they regard them to be the sound of appreciation for a well-cooked meal, the sign that it was a truly gratifying feast. In much the same way, the cooks take note when people slurp their soup (a sign of appreciation for a soup so tasty that people just won’t wait for it to cool down) or when they put away the silver and start eating with their hands (because the food is that ‘finger-licking’ good).
Every day, she would serve the orphans and the poor before she ever sat to eat at her table. Like the martyred mother of seven in the Book of Maccabees (cf. 2 Mc. 7:20-29), Margaret taught her children not to be held captive by the world or by whatever it offers. She nursed them with the milk of human kindness and fed them with the truths of divine faith. Three of her sons became kings of Scotland and in history are noted for their piety and justice. David, the youngest son, was so known for his holiness that we remember him less as a sovereign and more as a saint. The Divine Master had given Margaret her share of gold and instead of wasting her gift she used everything she had to build up the kingdom of God on Scottish soil.